Episode 34: Cassie Jo Stoddart — The Scream Murder

Hey Meat Bags!

On what should have been a quiet night of house sitting, 16-year-old Cassie Jo Stoddart found herself at the center of one of the most disturbing murders ever committed by teenagers. What investigators uncovered in the days that followed revealed a crime planned long before that Friday night—and a home video that captured just how far the killers were willing to go.

In September 2006, Cassie agreed to spend the weekend house-sitting for family in Pocatello, Idaho. After an evening spent with her boyfriend and friends, she was left alone in the house. Within minutes, the lights went out, strange noises echoed from downstairs, and someone was waiting in the darkness.

This week, Sam and Briana walk through the timeline of Cassie's final night, the investigation that unraveled in only a few days, the shocking confessions, and the disturbing evidence that exposed a calculated plan inspired by horror films and a desire for notoriety. They also discuss the lasting impact the case had on Cassie's family and why this murder continues to stand out as one of the most chilling crimes committed by teenagers.

Roll up a fatty of Strawberry Kush Pop for this one.

New episodes every Wednesday.

Strain of the Day

Strawberry Kush Pop

Have a case suggestion? Fill out our case suggestion form!

Follow Us

Instagram | TikTok | Facebook | X

Join our Patreon: Kush & Crime: A True Crime Potcast | Patreon

Support the show: Kush & Crime: A True Crime Potcast

Stay Safe, Stay Lifted, and try not to spiral — Sam & Briana